In a recent article for The Nation, Dave Zirin, host of Edge of Sports, described a recent national march in support of Israel held in DC as a hate rally. This incurred the wrath of Senator Chuck Schumer, who has accused our very own Dave of anti-Semitism. Dave Zirin responds in this special edition of “Choice Words.”
Studio Production: David Hebden
Post-Production: Taylor Hebden
Audio Post-Production: David Hebden
Opening Sequence: Cameron Granadino
Music by: Eze Jackson & Carlos Guillen
Transcript
Dave Zirin: Welcome to Edge of Sports only on The Real News Network. I’m Dave Zirin and I have some choice words about a burgeoning, heated debate between Senator Chuck Schumer and me. Yes, you heard that correctly. So let’s go. Okay, look, at first I was shocked when Chuck Schumer standing in the well of the US Senate called an article I wrote antisemitic. I was told his problem was that I described last month’s massive Stand With Israel march, where Schumer spoke,” a hate rally.”
I was gratified that he’d seen the piece and I was ready to argue that the anti-Palestinian hate on display that day, as well as the platforming of anti-Jewish Christian Zionists, gave me more than enough validity for my harsh description. But then I read Schumer’s full remarks – Remember, said in the well of the US Senate – And I was horrified. As a proud Jewish dude, I was shocked that Schumer would use my article as an example along with synagogue vandalization and Nazi hate crimes as part of a rising tide of antisemitism.
But by the way, in his litany of antisemitic examples, Elon Musk’s recent actions curiously did not merit a mention. Look, let’s be clear, Schumer is weaponizing the incendiary charge of antisemitism against me and the magazine where I wrote the article, The Nation, as a cover to slander the left, generally, and specifically the movement of a new generation of Jews marching and getting arrested in the name of a permanent ceasefire. He is also obfuscating his own craven efforts to ally with antisemites and genocidal Israeli politicians in the name of this war on Gaza.
Is that too harsh? Am I being too harsh? Well, I attended the Stand With Israel rally, like Chuck Schumer, and I know what I saw. I saw Chuck Schumer join hands with Christian Zionist, speaker of the House Mike Johnson, and share a stage with notorious anti-Jewish bigot Reverend John Hagee. I also saw a rousing ovation for Israeli president Isaac Herzog, who has recently called for a total war on all Palestinians saying, “It’s an entire nation that’s responsible.” In addition, I saw a way-over-his-head Van Jones call for peace only to be shouted down by the crowd as he stumbled off the stage.
Now, Schumer either spent that day with his head in the sand or he supports these kinds of alliances, and my fear is that it’s the latter. Calling the rally a hate rally could not have been more appropriate. Also, let’s be clear, antisemitism is not criticizing an intensely pro-war rally held in your home city, days after thousands marched for a ceasefire and lasting peace; Antisemitism is when people like Schumer bind Zionism, a 150-year-old political ideology, and Judaism, a 5,000-year old religion, to such a repugnant degree that he wants the world to believe that Israeli war crimes are being justly committed in our name as Jews. In addition, Schumer’s desire to hand over billions in weapons to the Elon Musk and the Christian Zionist-supporting government of Benjamin Netanyahu also aids antisemitism. He is providing cover for people who despise our faith because they also unconditionally support Israel’s total war on Gazan civilians.
So Chuck Schumer, heal thyself and stop supporting war crimes being committed in our name. This posture is dangerous to Jews everywhere because it stokes even more antisemitism. I have to say, I’m also disturbed that Schumer would choose this week to engage in these attacks, a week where so many of us are still in shock over the shooting of three Palestinian US college students in Burlington, Vermont. The war has come home and Schumer’s instinct in the face of these fires is to put it out with gasoline.
So let me be clear; Senator Chuck Schumer, you are invited to come onto The Real News Network with me and debate these questions of who in fact is aiding antisemitism. I will posit that it’s you. The invitation’s out there, we’ll see what you say. For The Real News Network and Edge of Sports, I’m Dave Zirin.
Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.
